Attorney Advertising
Truck Accident Lawyer in NYC
A truck accident is not a car accident. The vehicles are heavier, the federal rules layer on top of the New York no-fault system, and the liability chain is longer. An Amazon delivery van with the Amazon logo on the side is operated by a Delivery Service Partner contractor, who hires the driver. Three potential defendants. A FedEx Ground "independent contractor" route is still subject to FedEx operational control rules that create vicarious liability. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Call 718-261-0546.
Amazon, FedEx, UPS: who do you sue?
The most common truck case in NYC today is a delivery van or local delivery truck collision. The driver delivered for Amazon, FedEx, or UPS. The truck has the corporate logo. The driver works for the corporate brand.
That is rarely the whole story.
Amazon delivery vans are operated by Delivery Service Partner (DSP) companies. Amazon contracts last-mile delivery to dozens of small DSP businesses across NYC. The driver works for the DSP. The DSP employs the driver. Amazon dispatches the route, brands the van, and sets the schedule. We name all three: driver, DSP, and Amazon. The corporate defense is that the DSP is an independent contractor, and Amazon is not vicariously liable. The reality is that Amazon's operational control, route assignment, and equipment branding routinely create vicarious liability under New York case law and the federal motor carrier regulations.
FedEx Ground uses an independent-contractor route model. The driver owns the route, leases the truck, and contracts with FedEx Ground. FedEx Ground's position is that the driver is independent. Federal regulations under 49 CFR §390.5 and recent operational-control rulings still create vicarious liability when FedEx exercises sufficient control. We pull the route contract and the FedEx Ground operating manual to establish control.
UPS drivers are direct UPS employees in most cases (Teamsters Local 804 in NYC). UPS itself is the defendant under respondeat superior. The cases are procedurally cleaner but UPS defends them hard given the size of their fleet exposure.
The 18-wheeler case
Interstate commercial trucks (tractor-trailers, box trucks over 26,001 pounds gross, hazardous-material carriers) are governed by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations under 49 CFR Parts 390-399. These are federal rules that govern hours of service, vehicle maintenance, driver qualification, drug and alcohol testing, and cargo securement. Violations of any of these rules are direct evidence of negligence under New York law.
The minimum interstate insurance coverage is $750,000 for general freight under the MCS-90 endorsement, scaling up to $5 million for hazardous materials. That is the floor. Many carriers carry $1-5 million in primary plus excess umbrellas.
The key federal rules we look at in every 18-wheeler case:
- Hours of Service (49 CFR Part 395). Drivers cannot drive more than 11 hours after 10 consecutive hours off duty. The driver's electronic log records every minute. We subpoena the log.
- Vehicle Inspection (49 CFR Part 396). Pre-trip and post-trip inspection reports are required. Brake failures, tire blowouts, and steering issues that lead to crashes almost always trace back to an inspection failure.
- Drug and Alcohol Testing (49 CFR Part 382). Post-crash testing is mandatory for any crash involving a fatality, a tow-away, or a citation. We pull the test results immediately.
- Driver Qualification (49 CFR Part 391). Carriers are required to verify driving history, physical qualification, and CDL status. A driver who should not have been hired is direct negligence against the carrier.
Preserving the EDR data
Modern trucks carry an Event Data Recorder that captures speed, brake application, steering input, and engine status for the seconds before and after a crash. The EDR data overwrites or gets purged in routine maintenance within days to weeks. We send a spoliation preservation letter to the carrier, the driver, and the broker within 24 hours of intake. Without that letter, the EDR data can disappear and with it goes the strongest objective evidence of what the truck was actually doing at the moment of impact.
Same for dashcam footage and cab-facing driver-monitoring cameras. Many fleets (Amazon DSP, UPS, large commercial carriers) run continuous dashcam systems. The retention windows are short.
Garbage and sanitation trucks
NYC Department of Sanitation trucks are operated by the City. The 90-day Notice of Claim under General Municipal Law §50-e applies. The lawsuit then runs on the one-year-and-90-day clock under GML §50-i.
Private waste haulers (most commercial buildings contract with companies like Action Carting, Filco, Royal Waste) follow the standard three-year statute. We pull the contract chain (building manager → waste hauler → driver) and the safety record from the NYC Business Integrity Commission.
Construction trucks
Cement mixers, dump trucks, lowboys hauling equipment, crane carriers. These are commercial vehicles operating under their own carrier authority plus the construction project's general contractor control. Multiple layers of insurance and multiple potential defendants. We name everyone with operational or supervisory control over the truck at the time of the crash.
What the case is worth
Truck crash settlements vary widely based on injury severity, the carrier's coverage, the strength of liability evidence, and the venue. Catastrophic-injury truck cases regularly settle in the seven-figure range when the federal regulations are clearly violated and the medical case is strong. Soft-tissue cases with limited treatment settle for less. Wrongful-death truck cases against well-insured commercial carriers can reach eight figures.
Nick handled a $2 million Brooklyn DOE construction case in 2024 that turned in part on a truck-related falling-object claim. That case anchors our truck-case experience even though most of our truck volume is local delivery and commercial fleet, not 18-wheeler interstate.
What to do after a truck crash
- Call 911. Police report is required for any commercial-truck crash with injuries.
- Photograph everything. Truck, truck markings (DOT number, MC number, company logo, license plate), the scene, your injuries.
- Get the driver's license, registration, and insurance card. Plus the company's emergency response number (usually printed on the truck cab).
- Get to the ER. Even if you feel fine.
- Do not talk to the carrier's insurance adjuster. They will call within 24-48 hours offering quick cash. Refer them to your lawyer.
- Call us within the first 72 hours. We file spoliation preservation letters before the EDR data is overwritten.
Concierge service: we come to you
You do not have to come to the office. Our intake team meets you at home, the hospital, the rehab facility, or anywhere in NYC or Long Island. The Forest Hills office is for legal mail.
Talk to Nick
Free consultation. No fee unless we win. More than twenty years on personal injury cases in New York. Call 718-261-0546 or tell us what happened. Hablamos español.
Related: Personal Injury Lawyer NYC · Car Accident Lawyer Queens · Bus Accidents · Construction Accidents and Labor Law 240 · Amazon, FedEx, UPS Delivery Truck Scenario
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This page is informational and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different. The information here reflects general principles of New York personal injury law and is not a substitute for legal advice on your specific situation.
Law Offices of Nicholas Rose, PLLC | 102-11 Metropolitan Avenue, Forest Hills, NY 11375 | (718) 261-0546 | nicholas@nroselaw.com
Common questions.
Both, and the Delivery Service Partner (DSP) in between. Amazon contracts last-mile delivery to DSP companies that hire the drivers. The driver is the immediate negligent actor, the DSP is their employer (respondeat superior), and Amazon has dispatch and routing control that can pull them in too. We name all three and let the indemnification fight play out among them, while pursuing the deepest pocket for the actual recovery.
No. FedEx Ground uses independent-contractor routes, but federal regulations (FMCSA 49 CFR §390.5 and the recent rulings on operational control) still create vicarious liability when FedEx exercises sufficient control over routes, equipment, branding, and dispatch. We pull the contract, the FedEx Ground operating manual, and the dispatch records to establish control. The contractor label is a defense argument, not a case-ender.
Five things, all of which can disappear within days. (1) The truck's event-data recorder, which logs speed, brake application, and engine status for the seconds before impact. (2) The driver's hours-of-service log under FMCSA Part 395. (3) Pre-trip and post-trip inspection reports under FMCSA Part 396. (4) Dashcam or cab-facing camera footage. (5) The driver's drug and alcohol test results under Part 382. We send preservation letters to the carrier, the driver, and the broker within 24 hours of intake.
Most commercial trucks crossing into NYC are interstate carriers governed by FMCSA federal rules. Venue is in the borough where the crash happened (Queens for JFK / LaGuardia / Long Island Expressway corridor cases; Manhattan for Lincoln / Holland Tunnel cases; Brooklyn for BQE). Insurance minimums for interstate trucks start at $750,000 under the MCS-90 endorsement and scale up to $5 million for hazardous-material carriers. New York no-fault still applies to your car damage and the first $50,000 of medical bills.
If it is a NYC Department of Sanitation truck, yes, the City is the defendant and the 90-day Notice of Claim under GML §50-e applies. Private waste haulers (most commercial buildings contract privately) follow the standard three-year statute. The truck markings tell you who to sue, photograph them at the scene if you can.
Almost always. Rear-end collisions create a presumption of negligence against the rear driver under VTL §1129(a). The UPS defense is limited to sudden stops by the front driver or genuine emergencies; both are hard to prove. We push for early summary judgment on liability in clean rear-end UPS cases and focus the litigation on damages.
Free consultation. No fee unless we win.
Call 718-261-0546 or use the form. I answer my own phone during business hours, and the answering service patches urgent calls through after hours.
More than twenty years on these cases. Boutique New York City practice with a real team behind it. Bilingual intake team. Hablamos español. Arabic spoken on request.